skip to Main Content

SEED OILS ARE UNHEALTHY EVEN IN INSULIN SENSITIVE PEOPLE

image_pdfPDFimage_printPrint

DietDoctor.com
April 2021

Dr Scher: In presence of sufficient energy & insulin…
-linoleic acid can
~be detrimental to fat cells
~cause improper growth
~lead to insulin resistance

If someone was on hypocaloric diet, or
-had low insulin levels, then?

Yes, in context of metabolic function…
-in a state of low energy & low insulin
~the negative effects of linoleic acid & related peroxides
at the fat cell would be mitigated
-not allowing adipogenesis because:
~no stimulus for it

Instead, there is stimulus for:
-lipogenesis (hypertrophy…cell size growth)

Adipogenesis

formation of adipocytes (fat cells) from stem cells

Lipogenesis

acetyl-CoA converts into triglycerides for storage as fat

I am not saying…
-lipid peroxides are not damaging in other ways
-they alter mitochondria, while
-altering the lipid profile &
-cardiolipin (part of inner mitochondrial membrane)

So, even in low energy & low insulin:
Cannot give linoleic acid a green light

Dr Scher:
How would you rank the types of studies in nutrition?

Observational studies are the worst…
-clinical studies are the best
-mechanistic studies explain what happened in the others
(or, they don’t are results are irrelevant…only at cell level)

Observational studies (food consumption surveys)…
-so many biases get worked into them, such as:

Healthy user bias, for example:
-those who avoid saturated fat because heard unhealthy,
-so consume large amounts of seed oils
-they also have healthy habits in general
-these habits are not accounted for
in the survey

Observational studies (food consumption surveys)…
-so many biases get worked into them

These are plagues of nutrition science

“epidemiology (observational or survey)
should not be used in nutrition,
only in true disease research”

Big clinical studies…
-Minnesota Coronary Experiment
-Sydney Heart Study

These were as good as you can get:
-controlled the environment
-over many, many years
-long enough to measure death

These totally refuted the idea that
-polyunsaturated fats
are better than saturated fats

“Actually a net negative to cutting back on
saturated and focusing on polyunsaturated
fat (seed oils)”

close

WANT MORE?

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE INFO ON THE LATEST DOCTORS, TOPICS AND VIDEOS!
We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

This Post Has 0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.